Start most Commander decks at 37 lands. Move down only when the deck has cheap spells, reliable draw, and low-cost ramp. Move up when the commander is expensive, the curve is high, or missing land drops would be disastrous.

Why 37 is a useful baseline

Commander games are long and decks contain 99 library cards, so consistency matters. Thirty-seven lands plus roughly ten pieces of ramp gives a typical casual deck enough early mana sources without flooding every game.

Count more than lands

Mana rocks, land-search spells, and cheap draw improve consistency, but they do not all replace lands equally. A three-mana ramp spell cannot help a one-land opening hand. Count sources by when they become usable.

Reasons to add lands

Your commander costs six or more; the deck wants landfall triggers; your average mana value is high; you have few cheap draw spells; or you frequently miss the fourth and fifth land drops.

Reasons to trim carefully

Your average mana value is very low; the commander creates mana or cards; you run many one- and two-mana ramp effects; or the deck has deliberate land-recursion and selection engines. Test before cutting.

How to test

Goldfish ten opening hands. Record keeps, mulligans, and whether you can make land drops through turn four. Then play real games and track mana problems separately from color problems.

The short version

Use 37 as a starting point, not a law. Change two cards at a time and test the result.